On
July 14 Garry Kasparov gave a discussion and book signing for his new book
"My Great Predecessors,
Part I" at a Barnes & Noble bookstore in New York City. After
the signing he took questions from the audience. A transcript is below,
followed by further comments on his upcoming FIDE match with Ponomariov
and his match with Fritz that was just announced.
Q: How long did it take to write the parts you've written so far?
Much of it was done, was started, in pieces earlier, and for
the last three years I've been working extensively on the book. And I'm now
working on Karpov, which is for volume three. There is something that could
change the entire framework. The games are getting longer, more complex as we
progress. We may increase the number of volumes to four because the history of
classical chess would not be complete without all of the Karpov-Kasparov
matches. So the project can grow, the project is in command. It is dictating
our work. Then volume five will be my own games. As for the first three you can
expect the third volume by the end of 2004.
Writing the book I
discovered many things. I wanted it to be a history of classical chess so I had
to include the crucial games from all the matches. These books are not the
final version, the final analysis. They are material to enjoy and to start
asking questions.
Q: I'm a psychoanalyst. What are the most important characteristics
to become a champion chessplayer?
That's an excellent question. Psychology is an important part of the book,
which isn't only about world champions but about those others who had
made massive contributions to chess, but who fell short. And when reading
about those other players you can see they often fell just an inch short.
In certain cases they had more impact on chess and its development than
those who did become champions. To reach the title you have to be exceptional
and you have to look at psychology. It's not just about finding the best
move, about moving the chess pieces, but about being able to show your
best qualities at the right moment. That's why psychology played a very
important role in the history of classical chess. I would say that most
of the key matches were decided by the psychological hype. One could resist
the pressure and the other could not.
Q: How do you see the future of chess? It seems to be changing.
That's one of the important things about this book, it is a sort of museum
of classical chess. Chess IS changing and I don't think we should be upset
about it. It shows the strength of the game of chess, it is adjusting
to the technological era. It's an ancient game and now it's on the internet
and you have rapid chess. But at the same time it is losing it's scientific
element. Classical chess is what created the image of chess and it is
important to remember that, to put all these great moments on the record.
Q: Did you use computer programs to analyze variations in the book?
This book couldn't appear without having a computer. To find the true
story, to get into the small details of the big fights, they are critical.
I'm not sure that I made all the correct analysis, but it's very important
to analyze deeply. The lines in the book are shorter, I had to cut many
of them down, some were even discarded. But what was important was for
me to see the details, all the hidden dynamics of the games so I could
explain what was there and come up with the true story of the game.
What is fascinating is that now even amateurs can find mistakes in a book
by the world number one. After the Russian edition came out two months
ago we received a number of comments from strong players and not very
strong players and some were very good. People were already finding mistakes,
which is excellent because it means people are reading the book seriously.
We are now planning to add a sort of diary to the next volumes including
the corrections and comments about the previous volumes. We can put this
on the internet, as well.
This is important because these are the best games ever played, they are
the games with the greatest ideas ever played in the game of chess. It's
not just for Garry Kasparov or some top players to participate in this
debate, it's open to everybody. It is thanks to computers that this debate
is open to the general public. If you know how to work with the computer
and if you have time and patience to find the truth you can find refutations.
Everything I published I believed correct, was the way to go, but I know
there will be more discoveries and I hope average chess fans will be able
to contribute as well.
Q: [From Russian television reporter] We know you are
not just a chess player, that you were involved in Russian politics as
well. What is your opinion of the current Russian situation...
That's a long story but I think I would like to stick to chess and to
the book here. The people here, the majority aren't Russian and most,
frankly speaking, don't care about Russian politics! You know my opinions,
I haven't changed them. I'm very critical of the current Russian administration.
But it's a long story and unfortunately to change things in Russia will
take more time than to write this book!
Q: Which player from the past would you most like to play? Assuming
they had your knowledge of modern chess.
You can't compare Newton and Einstein, each player is of his time. If
you show Steinitz what has happened in the last 100 years he would no
longer be Steinitz, he would be a different player. Fischer with all modern
knowledge of current chess would be sort of Kasparov. That's why it's
not fair to compare someone at the end of the 20th century with someone
who lived fifty or sixty years ago.
I'm very bad at ranking the champions and the great players of the past.
You can read the book, make your own choice, pick your own best player
because you like him. But it will be very subjective. I couldn't afford
the luxury of having a favorite because otherwise you would see a big
difference in that chapter. I refrain from giving negative remarks and
I anticipate now that the best parts of the series will be written about
Karpov. I'm sticking to the contributions of the greatest players to the
game of chess. I give anecdotes, stories, a lot of information but it's
up to you to make the final judgment.
Later we spoke with Kasparov about a few other
items on his agenda.
When is the last time you spoke with FIDE about your match with Ponomariov?
I don't know, it's been a long time, probably months. It's only 12 weeks
until they say the match will start and I still haven't seen a contract!
My financial losses are piling up, I don't know when I am going to play
next. It's all politics at this point.
Do you feel Ponomariov will have a home-field advantage in Yalta?
It's clear it wouldn't be my first choice but I'm more interested in it
happening at all at this point.
Your November
X3D match against Fritz
was just announced yesterday. Will it help to study the games Kramnik
played against the program last year?
Absolutely, you learn a lot. They can make changes of course but it's
very important to have all the information you can get. Even though our
version of Junior was quite old by the time the match started it was useful.
After the games we could reproduce just about everything. Everything except
for 10...Bxh2 [in game five], actually. But even there we could see what
it was doing, that the evaluations were just good for it.
More importantly it's good that X3D is still supporting this experiment,
still supporting science. This match will be more progress, showing the
public we are doing new things.
Junior
is considered a superior tactical program, that Fritz
is more solid, etc. Is there a significant difference to you in which
program you play?
All the top programs are strong, the difference is in how they handle
complex middlegame positions. You can see that now only the top players
in the world can play with them. Kramnik and I, the top two players in
the world, draw matches and the machines are always getting stronger.
But we are learning too and I am still confident I can win the match.
Garry
Kasparov on my Great Predecessors, Part 1 £25/$35
Available for immediate shipping.
Click here
for a full description of the book and ordering information. |